https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEoPUL_W_vo
The ad uses a large, strong, intimidating gentleman as the visual representation of the product. This advertisement combines the themes of Violence as a Genetically Programmed Male Behavior and The Association of Muscularity with Ideal Masculinity. In the ad the scenery/environment shows that this is not today's society, it is back in history. On MillerCoors press release about the product they stated,
The Smith & Forge packaging features a black, bold orange, and antique white design and a distinctive blacksmith’s hammer icon that delivers a timeless message of a past era - an homage to simpler times when toughness and hard work were celebrated values.
“Once upon a time, barrel-chested men proudly drank tankards of hard cider,” continued Kroll. “Smith & Forge is honoring those times by bringing back the sturdy side of hard cider.”
This clearly reinforces the ideological premise that Katz discusses in his article that "men have always been aggressive and brutal." He says that using history to reflect the ideology is disguising it as if it should be common sense. MillerCoors even uses the stereotype in their release saying "barrel-chested men".
The advertisement also reflects the idea that big and strong means you are a man. What they are trying to say in this ad is "This guy back here yelling at rocks is super strong so he is therefore manly" which then projects the idea that if I drink this "hard cider" I will be more like this guy which therefore means I am more manly.
This definitely reflects the idea of "mask-ulinity" and is not a great representation of masculinity in society. BUT, if you ask me how this can be improved to better represent masculinity...I don't think it can. In order to improve the ads representation of masculinity you would have to completely change the ideology behind it. This ad is effective in what it is trying to do, they aren't the ones that created this stereotype and ideology. They are just using it in order to reach a target market and that is the number one job that marketers are concerned about. These types of ads will continue to be produced because they continue to have success.
To wrap things up, I personally thought this commercial was funny and to be honest after I saw it the next alcoholic beverage I purchased was a 12 pack of Smith and Forge Hard Cider. Did I buy it because I was feeling insecure about my masculinity? Did I buy it because I support the ideologies behind the product? or Did I buy it because I thought a large man yelling at a rock was funny and wanted something new to drink on a Saturday? Who knows...but I do know two things for sure.....
1. masculinity will continue to be portrayed like this in the media because it is successful
2. I don't like hard cider
peace, love, LAXXXXXXXXXXX
Tim
The Smith & Forge packaging features a black, bold orange, and antique white design and a distinctive blacksmith’s hammer icon that delivers a timeless message of a past era - an homage to simpler times when toughness and hard work were celebrated values.
“Once upon a time, barrel-chested men proudly drank tankards of hard cider,” continued Kroll. “Smith & Forge is honoring those times by bringing back the sturdy side of hard cider.”
This clearly reinforces the ideological premise that Katz discusses in his article that "men have always been aggressive and brutal." He says that using history to reflect the ideology is disguising it as if it should be common sense. MillerCoors even uses the stereotype in their release saying "barrel-chested men".
The advertisement also reflects the idea that big and strong means you are a man. What they are trying to say in this ad is "This guy back here yelling at rocks is super strong so he is therefore manly" which then projects the idea that if I drink this "hard cider" I will be more like this guy which therefore means I am more manly.
This definitely reflects the idea of "mask-ulinity" and is not a great representation of masculinity in society. BUT, if you ask me how this can be improved to better represent masculinity...I don't think it can. In order to improve the ads representation of masculinity you would have to completely change the ideology behind it. This ad is effective in what it is trying to do, they aren't the ones that created this stereotype and ideology. They are just using it in order to reach a target market and that is the number one job that marketers are concerned about. These types of ads will continue to be produced because they continue to have success.
To wrap things up, I personally thought this commercial was funny and to be honest after I saw it the next alcoholic beverage I purchased was a 12 pack of Smith and Forge Hard Cider. Did I buy it because I was feeling insecure about my masculinity? Did I buy it because I support the ideologies behind the product? or Did I buy it because I thought a large man yelling at a rock was funny and wanted something new to drink on a Saturday? Who knows...but I do know two things for sure.....
1. masculinity will continue to be portrayed like this in the media because it is successful
2. I don't like hard cider
peace, love, LAXXXXXXXXXXX
Tim
